Gears of War: E-Day reviews: what critics said
Critics praised Horde Siege and the reworked movement in The Coalition's prequel; the main complaints were a long campaign and dull open areas.
Published 3 min read
Gears of War: E-Day, The Coalition’s prequel set on the day the Locust invasion began, launched on October 6, 2026, on Xbox Series X|S, Windows PC and Steam, after an early access period from October 1 for owners of the Premium Edition and Game Pass members with the Premium Upgrade, according to Xbox Wire. This roundup summarises, in our own words, what published reviews said, with a link to each. We have not reviewed the game ourselves and give no score of our own.
The scores
| Measure | Figure | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| OpenCritic Top Critic Average | 85 | OpenCritic’s Mighty band; 139 critic reviews listed |
| OpenCritic Critics Recommend | 89% | Reviews with a verdict |
| Metacritic Metascore | 87 | Generally Favorable; 63 positive and 9 mixed reviews, none negative, on the Xbox Series X page |
| Metacritic User Score | 8.5 | Generally Favorable, from 2,020 user ratings |
Metacritic lists separate pages by platform: 87 on Xbox Series X and 83 on PC. Figures are as the two sites showed them on November 10, 2026; at our first check, on October 13, the Top Critic Average was 87 and the main Metascore 88.
What critics praised
Horde Siege and the multiplayer. The new co-op wave mode is the most consistently praised part of the package. IGN, at 9 out of 10, called the campaign stellar and the multiplayer excellent, singling out Horde Siege as an evolution of Horde. GamingTrend, at 95 out of 100, called it the best version of the mode the series has had, and The Games Machine, at 9.2 out of 10, liked how the Versus mode brings back old-school multiplayer.
Movement and combat. Several reviews note that the reworked movement modernises the series without losing its weight. TechRaptor, at 9.5 out of 10, called E-Day the best game in the series, citing the improved movement and a wider range of weapons with mods. Even Wccftech, one of the cooler reviews at 7.4, said the shooting is better than ever.
Tone and setting. Eurogamer, at 4 out of 5, argued that looking back to the series’ roots helps it move forward, waist-high cover and machismo included. Shacknews, at 9 out of 10, praised the brutal, horror-leaning take on humans against monsters and the characters behind it. Polygon, which does not score, said the game is just about good enough to take the crown of Xbox’s leading franchise from Halo.
What critics criticised
A long campaign. The main complaint is about pacing. PC Gamer, at 77 out of 100, liked the cover shooting and the multiplayer but found the campaign an exhausting, endless firefight that overstays its welcome.
Story and open areas. GameSpot, at 7 out of 10, enjoyed the game as distinctly Gears but called the story disappointing and the open areas fairly dull. Wccftech went further, saying that in several ways it feels like a step back from Gears 5, with a less memorable story and forgettable side content.
Depth in Versus. GamingTrend, otherwise one of the most enthusiastic reviews, said the Versus mode lacks the depth to reward its steep learning curve.
How to read it
Its Top Critic Average sits in OpenCritic’s 98th percentile, and Metacritic counts no negative reviews among the 59 on its main platform page. Where they differ is over the campaign. Reviewers who came for multiplayer and Horde Siege rated it highest; those who judged mainly the story mode, such as PC Gamer and GameSpot, scored it in the 70s. If you play Gears mainly for the campaign, read those two reviews first.
For how these aggregate scores are calculated, see our guide to how Metacritic and OpenCritic scores work.
Sources
- OpenCritic: Gears of War: E-Day (checked November 10, 2026)
- Metacritic: Gears of War: E-Day (checked November 10, 2026)
- Xbox Wire: Gears of War: E-Day early access launch (October 1, 2026)
- IGN review (Ryan McCaffrey)
- Eurogamer review (Dom Peppiatt)
- PC Gamer review (Abbie Stone)
- GameSpot review (Richard Wakeling)
- Wccftech review (Alessio Palumbo)
- TechRaptor review (Austin Suther)
- GamingTrend review (David Burdette)
- The Games Machine review (Alessandro Alosi)
- Shacknews review (Sam Chandler)
- Polygon review (Ford James)